The NYC subway shooter bears responsibility for his crimes

In the near week since Frank James’ alleged Brooklyn subway attack, it’s become accepted wisdom that New York City’s or America’s social-services system failed him — and us. Yet no one has shown any way in which social services could have stopped this attack. What we have is what it looks like: a bad guy who intelligently planned and executed a bad thing.

After the mass shooting, City Councilwoman Alexa Avilés and Assemblywoman Marcela Mitaynes, who represent Sunset Park, said that it showed how “we need investments in social services — housing, healthcare and education.” Politico wondered “What Brooklyn’s subway shooting reveals about the state of mental health care.”

so far? nothing.

True, New York City and state leave seriously mentally ill people on the street, despite multiple warning signs. Some of those people, like Martial Simon, who pushed Michelle Go to her death under a subway in January, are violent. Simon had a documented history of delusions and compulsions so severe that he couldn’t function.

James is not that person. James, though born in New York, has no apparent recent ties to the city. Until Wednesday, he hadn’t been arrested here in nearly a quarter-century.

He doesn’t fit the profile of Simon or the people accused of killing Christina Yuna Lee and Krystal Bayron-Nieves this year: people recently arrested and released, despite escalating episodes of uncontrolled violent impulses.

James claimed, in his video rants, that New York’s mental-health system failed him, but he didn’t say when or how. If the education system failed him, it did so five decades ago. (Maybe the lack of charter schools back then failed him.)

Brooklyn shooting
People get help from other commuters following the April 12 subway shooting in Brooklyn.
AP/Will B Wylde

Our housing system didn’t fail him, unless it fails everyone who leaves New York for a different city for one reason or another. He found housing in Milwaukee and an Airbnb in Philly.

Should social services run by Milwaukee or some other city have noticed James’ YouTube screeds, in which he said white people “kill and commit genocide against each other” and will do the same to “your black ass,” declared that “white people and black people . † † should not have any contact with each other” and praised 9/11 as “a beautiful day”?

These are disordered thoughts — and, as Mayor Eric Adams said last week, big tech should stop allowing people to amplify disordered thoughts.

But you are allowed to have disordered thoughts. You’re allowed to think 9/11 was an inside job; you’re allowed to have bizarre racial theories.

Frank James
James, the alleged Brooklyn subway shooter, posted multiple concerning videos on social media prior to the attack.
YouTube / prophetoftruth88

There’s no getting around the fact that James was functional. As he said himself, huh chose not to work consistently for a living: “There’s no way that I’m going to . † † go to work, pay my taxes.”

He was functional enough to plot a complex ideological attack across geographic boundaries and carry it out.

He was functional enough to compile the equipment he needed, to disguise himself as an MTA construction worker, to discard his disguise immediately so that he could escape. He even arranged his own judgment.

There’s a whiff of patronizing racism in assuming that James didn’t do exactly what he set out to do but rather “needed help.”

New York City Police Department personnel gather at the entrance to a subway stop.
NYPD personnel stand outside of the subway entrance where the April 12 shooting occurred.
John Minchillo/AP

Anyone who commits a mass attack has mental problems. Timothy McVeigh, the Oklahoma City bomber, probably did have post-traumatic stress disorder, and Boston Marathon bomber Dzhokhar Tsarnaev probably used to be manipulated by his mastermind brother. The 9/11 hijackers also (apparently!) had disordered thoughts.

Nobody ever says he needed housing services.

Like these other attackers, James knows right from wrong and action and consequence. In one video, he said that “I wanted to kill people” but “I don’t want to go to f–king prison.”

Should the FBI have zeroed in on the videos James posted just before his attack, when he used more menacing language, saying, for example, that “it’s time”?

Law enforcement officials lead subway shooting suspect Frank R. James, 62, right, away from a police station and into a vehicle.
NYPD escort James into a police vehicle following his arrest.
John Minchillo/AP

Sure, but that’s law enforcement, not social services. Plus, James made no direct threats — more evidence of careful planning.

It may be a good idea for social-services agencies to interact more with people like James. But there are a lot of such people: people on the border of society, with plenty of time to cultivate loony ideas.

Is New York City going to hunt each of these people down and provide him with an apartment and daily intensive counseling so that he doesn’t make a cross-country trip here to attack us?

Nicole Gelinas is a contributing editor to the Manhattan Institute’s City Journal.

Leave a Comment